Empty Comments on Reviews
Moderator: AniDB
-
- Posts: 38
- Joined: Fri Jun 30, 2006 7:54 pm
- Location: Upstate NY
- Contact:
Feel free to message me whenever you get a bad (or good) score from me though
But really, I think it will only result in less 'bad' ratings being given. That will tip the balance, imho. When people get 'punished' (by a popup) for giving a bad rating, people will abstain from giving them. That`s my main concern. And seeing how we already get few votes in the first place, I don`t think we should discourage people voting.
Perhaps you like getting less bad votes, but I think it won`t be a proper rating in the end anymore, if the people who think your review is not good enough won`t vote anymore.
In that way, if you want to enforce this, you better remove the 1 and 3 votes completely instead - would have the same effect
But really, I think it will only result in less 'bad' ratings being given. That will tip the balance, imho. When people get 'punished' (by a popup) for giving a bad rating, people will abstain from giving them. That`s my main concern. And seeing how we already get few votes in the first place, I don`t think we should discourage people voting.
Perhaps you like getting less bad votes, but I think it won`t be a proper rating in the end anymore, if the people who think your review is not good enough won`t vote anymore.
In that way, if you want to enforce this, you better remove the 1 and 3 votes completely instead - would have the same effect
-
- Posts: 38
- Joined: Fri Jun 30, 2006 7:54 pm
- Location: Upstate NY
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 11:55 am
- Location: Florence, Italy
A "report" feature is needed. I'm sure everyone knows what kind of comemnts reviewers get, but just in case:
From the comments on my review of FF7:AC:
17.09.05 01:37 schmodawg (100893) 1 I guess you need to watch the movie again, there is a story it revolves around geostigma and kadaj trying to bring back sephiroth. the whole movie is about stopping them from doing it, which is its plot. cloud also gains his will to fight because if he doesnt win sephiroth is gonna kill everyone and use earth to fly around space. It wasnt rushed either like you say, remember how long it took to come out, if you look at the level of detail put into there is no way you can even say it. Everything really revolves around cloud like you said because its a movie about him. This isnt an anime series either how could they go into such detail on every character. oh and by the way the value is pretty damn high seeing how I and a dozen or so of my friends have watched this at least 3-4 times each because its so good, maybe you should wait till the italian version comes out and write another review.
^ Patronizing + it just disagrees
01.12.05 22:30 Final Fantasy VII - Advent Children gseed (27868) 6 ok..
^ Wow!
25.07.06 21:20 chopper87 (161844) 10 Er. Yeah. Whatever.
^ ........
My Speed Grapher review:
10.09.06 09:25 harrize (164639) 6 Hey, hey. 6 votes for 10 in a row? Isn`t it suspicious a little? My vote is 6, pal.
^ WTF??
Thank God I have a sense of humor -__-
From the comments on my review of FF7:AC:
17.09.05 01:37 schmodawg (100893) 1 I guess you need to watch the movie again, there is a story it revolves around geostigma and kadaj trying to bring back sephiroth. the whole movie is about stopping them from doing it, which is its plot. cloud also gains his will to fight because if he doesnt win sephiroth is gonna kill everyone and use earth to fly around space. It wasnt rushed either like you say, remember how long it took to come out, if you look at the level of detail put into there is no way you can even say it. Everything really revolves around cloud like you said because its a movie about him. This isnt an anime series either how could they go into such detail on every character. oh and by the way the value is pretty damn high seeing how I and a dozen or so of my friends have watched this at least 3-4 times each because its so good, maybe you should wait till the italian version comes out and write another review.
^ Patronizing + it just disagrees
01.12.05 22:30 Final Fantasy VII - Advent Children gseed (27868) 6 ok..
^ Wow!
25.07.06 21:20 chopper87 (161844) 10 Er. Yeah. Whatever.
^ ........
My Speed Grapher review:
10.09.06 09:25 harrize (164639) 6 Hey, hey. 6 votes for 10 in a row? Isn`t it suspicious a little? My vote is 6, pal.
^ WTF??
Thank God I have a sense of humor -__-
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Sun Jan 09, 2005 10:54 am
- Location: Germany
-
- Posts: 38
- Joined: Fri Jun 30, 2006 7:54 pm
- Location: Upstate NY
- Contact:
Dude, that's awesome. Chopper is a demigod and he has blessed you. If your review was bad, you would KNOW, man, you would KNOW.Lepaca Kliffoth wrote: 25.07.06 21:20 chopper87 (161844) 10 Er. Yeah. Whatever.
^ ........
Anyways, feedback for reviews is a good thing, reporting idiotic feedback is a great thing. Count me as supporting a report feature.
-
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 11:55 am
- Location: Florence, Italy
-
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 11:55 am
- Location: Florence, Italy
Lol chopper just rated my Higurashi review, that guy has issues I like his style, though.albinosqrl wrote: Dude, that's awesome. Chopper is a demigod and he has blessed you. If your review was bad, you would KNOW, man, you would KNOW.
Anyways, feedback for reviews is a good thing, reporting idiotic feedback is a great thing. Count me as supporting a report feature.
-
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 11:55 am
- Location: Florence, Italy
-
- Posts: 38
- Joined: Fri Jun 30, 2006 7:54 pm
- Location: Upstate NY
- Contact: