[ALL-REQs] Categories (new genre system)
Moderator: AniDB
@TechNiko did you add those categories, like characters and genre, separately? Because when I add a category with the chain-add, it doesn't add categories like characters or genre.
EDIT: Do hollows fall under spirits or beasts? Or what else?
EDIT2: New suggestion: Place::Alternative World
Examples: Naruto and Scrapped Princess
Or a suggestion of what I should enter instead.
EDIT: Do hollows fall under spirits or beasts? Or what else?
EDIT2: New suggestion: Place::Alternative World
Examples: Naruto and Scrapped Princess
Or a suggestion of what I should enter instead.
haven't seen area88, is it actually _based_ on the old anime or are both simply using the same original work as base?Elias wrote:Origin::other anime
for remakes, like Area 88
if there are animes which are entirely based on another anime (which might only be evident if the original anime differed noticeably from it's original source) this category might indeed be usefull.
addedElias wrote:Characters::People::Soldiers
Characters::People::Soldiers::Pilots
BYe!
EXP
done, the remaining question is if "Characters::People" is a useful entry or not.sjabbie wrote:GunGrave
If you look at the categories here, the categories genre, setting, audience and characters are separately shown. Please wipe em :).
BYe!
EXP
What about animes which are sequels to titles based on manga (or something different) but itself are not connected to primary source (like AA! Megami-sama is based more or less on manga, but AA! Megami-sama - The Movie has original story not existing in manga, so marking it as based on manga would not be precise).exp wrote:haven't seen area88, is it actually _based_ on the old anime or are both simply using the same original work as base?Elias wrote:Origin::other anime
for remakes, like Area 88
if there are animes which are entirely based on another anime (which might only be evident if the original anime differed noticeably from it's original source) this category might indeed be usefull.
Maybe there are some cases, when this category can be usable, like some SF or fantasy, where are mostly demons, angels, ghosts, androids, aliens and only some not specific humans. But at least i would not take this category as parent category, only when is marked itself.exp wrote: done, the remaining question is if "Characters::People" is a useful entry or not.
I propose moving from Setting::Place genres: School, Office, Prison, Hospital, Mansion as subgenres of
Setting::Place::Buildings
Setting::Place::Buildings::Office
Setting::Place::Buildings::School
...
adding to them
Setting::Place::Buildings::Home
action take sometimes place inside normal houses.
moving Americas, Asia, Europe as subgenres of
Setting::Place::Earth
Setting::Place::Earth::Americas::United States
...
moving Dystopia, Mirror world as subgenres of
Setting::Place::Worlds
or
Setting::Place::Other worlds
Setting::Place::Worlds::Dystopia
Setting::Place::Worlds::Mirror world
Setting::Place::Worlds::Virtual Reality
Train could be then moved to
Setting::Place::Vehicles::Train
short summary from what i cought of the last few posts besides elias post
should be done
----
Setting::Place::Alternative World (or Setting::Place::Fantasy World) should already be taken care of with Setting::Place::other Worlds
Original work::Game::Dating sims - done
needs further discussion:
Add
---
Original Work::other anime
Move
-----
Action::Western to Action::Guns::Western
Rename
----
Original Work to Based on (or Origin)
applied elias suggestions as it structures the
Setting::Place::
what about Setting::Place::Marine and Setting::Place::Marine::Submarine ?
Original Work::other anime
I think we shouldn't add that. relations takes care of that.
lets take the AMS example.
all 3 are based upon the manga. some more some less. thats what the stars are for and relation takes care all 3 are connected.
should be done
----
Setting::Place::Alternative World (or Setting::Place::Fantasy World) should already be taken care of with Setting::Place::other Worlds
Original work::Game::Dating sims - done
needs further discussion:
Add
---
Original Work::other anime
Move
-----
Action::Western to Action::Guns::Western
Rename
----
Original Work to Based on (or Origin)
applied elias suggestions as it structures the
Setting::Place::
what about Setting::Place::Marine and Setting::Place::Marine::Submarine ?
Original Work::other anime
I think we shouldn't add that. relations takes care of that.
lets take the AMS example.
all 3 are based upon the manga. some more some less. thats what the stars are for and relation takes care all 3 are connected.
Last edited by Der Idiot on Wed Jul 06, 2005 10:29 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Moving to Setting::Place::Vehicles::Marine maybe?Der Idiot wrote: what about Setting::Place::Marine and Setting::Place::Marine::Submarine ?
Also then adding there:
Setting::Place::Vehicles::Cars
Setting::Place::Vehicles::Planes
Setting::Place::Vehicles::Other (for balloons or other rare vehicles)
Maybe also move
Setting::Place::Space::Shipboard
as
Setting::Place::Vehicles::Spaceships
Another propose:
Characters::Animals::Other
Characters::People::Other
For animals (cows, goldfishes, chickens, ...) or classes of people (thieves, artists, sportsmens, programmers), which maybe have now only one anime title containing it, but those genres would contain set of titles for choosing new subgenres (if it would be possible to add comment to genre it would be even better: Characters::Animals::Other with comment 'sharks')