Change of the voting grading system for animes [DONE/DENIED]

[Andemon]

Me too. We are fortunate to have such an expert coder in charge of AniDB. ^_^

Doesn't look like Anime Hint can (yet?) handle these new votes, though. I got the exact same scores when I tested it by rating one popular anime first 7.5, and then 8. I think it rounds the .5 votes up -- there should probably be some difference between them, for accuracy...

The weight table is currently set at:
0 => 40, 1 => 5, 2 => -20, 3 => -40, 4 => -60, 5 => -60, 6 => -60, 7 => -60, 8 => -60, 9 => -60

Hopefully it won't be too difficult to add 0.5, 1.5, and such to that scale...

[exp]

Me too. We are fortunate to have such an expert coder in charge of AniDB. ^_^

Doesn't look like Anime Hint can (yet?) handle these new votes, though. I got the exact same scores when I tested it by rating one popular anime first 7.5, and then 8. I think it rounds the .5 votes up -- there should probably be some difference between them, for accuracy...

The weight table is currently set at:
0 => 40, 1 => 5, 2 => -20, 3 => -40, 4 => -60, 5 => -60, 6 => -60, 7 => -60, 8 => -60, 9 => -60

Hopefully it won't be too difficult to add 0.5, 1.5, and such to that scale...

egg would have to look into that.
feel free to add a tracker item.

BYe!
EXP

[Amour]

Another solution could have been:

10 <-> AAA
9 <-> AA+
8 <-> AA
7 <-> A+
6 <-> A
5 <-> B
4 <-> C
3 <-> D
2 <-> E
1 <-> F

[rowaasr13]

You've forgot S, SS and SSS. :P

[segroove]

Now we have the .5 votes, great!

I'd like to see an option to change old votes by +/- 0.5, because a "revoke" would remove my old date here, and I couldn't see anymore when I watched the anime :/

[fei0x]

Having the .5 scale is great. But I'm noticing one problem. Now I want to revote all my anime to adjust for the .5's and I have to go each anime page and revoke and revote. It would be nice if we could change multiple votes at once on our myvotes page instead of having to jump back and forth through the db a lot.

[DonGato]

Something like check boxes at every vote side and an option to add/remove .5 or 1 to all of them?

[egg]

Doesn't look like Anime Hint can (yet?) handle these new votes, though. I got the exact same scores when I tested it by rating one popular anime first 7.5, and then 8. I think it rounds the .5 votes up -- there should probably be some difference between them, for accuracy...

The weight table is currently set at:
0 => 40, 1 => 5, 2 => -20, 3 => -40, 4 => -60, 5 => -60, 6 => -60, 7 => -60, 8 => -60, 9 => -60

Hopefully it won't be too difficult to add 0.5, 1.5, and such to that scale...

Implementing it shouldn't be difficult, the hard part is deciding what the new scales should be... So what weights should be applied to the .5 increments? This also needs to be decided for the loose scale:
0 => 10, 1 => 1, 2 => -1, 3 => -2, 4 => -4, 5 => -6, 6 => -8,
7 => -10, 8 => -12, 9 => -15

[Andemon]

Strict:
0 => 40, 0.5 => 20, 1 => 5, 1.5 => -10, 2 => -20, 2.5 => -30, 3 => -40, 3.5 => -50, 4 => -60, 4.5 => -60, 5 => -60, 5.5 => -60, 6 => -60, 6.5 => -60, 7 => -60, 7.5 => -60, 8 => -60, 8.5 => -60, 9 => -60

...or something like that. Loose is bit more difficult, if no fractions should be used... This is the best I could come up with, but that'd mean that 2.5 and 3 would end up sharing the same values. -_-;

Loose:
0 => 10, 0.5 = 4, 1 => 1, 1.5 => 0, 2 => -1, 2.5 => -2, 3 => -2, 3.5 => -3, 4 => -4, 4.5 => -5, 5 => -6, 5.5 => -7, 6 => -8, 6.5 => -9, 7 => -10, 7.5 = -11, 8 => -12, 8.5 => -14, 9 => -15