censored
Moderator: AniDB
-
- AniDB Staff
- Posts: 379
- Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2004 11:05 am
-
- Posts: 28
- Joined: Sat Jul 29, 2006 8:10 pm
I recall this being discused before, it was this:
http://www.anidb.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5586
Anyway, i have the same opinion.
http://www.anidb.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5586
Anyway, i have the same opinion.
I will also point out the case about “La Blue Girl”:
http://www.animeprime.com/reports/lbg.shtml
There was the Japanese version, with mosaic, then an English uncensored version, then a new English uncensored version which was in fact a cut of the previous one for legal reasons in USA.
This last version is written uncensored but isn't because it's shorter than the original.
Maybe we could have two distinctive tags:
*Censored/Uncensored (for the mosaic protection)
*Cut/Uncut (for any deletion)
http://www.animeprime.com/reports/lbg.shtml
There was the Japanese version, with mosaic, then an English uncensored version, then a new English uncensored version which was in fact a cut of the previous one for legal reasons in USA.
This last version is written uncensored but isn't because it's shorter than the original.
Maybe we could have two distinctive tags:
*Censored/Uncensored (for the mosaic protection)
*Cut/Uncut (for any deletion)
final decision to this:
- (un)censored flag get's limited to pron only
- a new cut flag gets introduced to mark actually cut out scenes. where "cut" stands for actually removed scenes. not just covered up things.
that's it. any other sort of weird stuff get's ignored. i.e. donkeys, crows, fog, beeped stuff. you may make a note in the groupcomments/groupstatus if you want. abusing filecomments for this is not wanted.
- (un)censored flag get's limited to pron only
- a new cut flag gets introduced to mark actually cut out scenes. where "cut" stands for actually removed scenes. not just covered up things.
that's it. any other sort of weird stuff get's ignored. i.e. donkeys, crows, fog, beeped stuff. you may make a note in the groupcomments/groupstatus if you want. abusing filecomments for this is not wanted.
-
- AniDB Staff
- Posts: 438
- Joined: Thu Apr 08, 2004 1:43 am
- Location: Portugal
another option would be to use ep comments, no?Der Idiot wrote:final decision to this:
- (un)censored flag get's limited to pron only
- a new cut flag gets introduced to mark actually cut out scenes. where "cut" stands for actually removed scenes. not just covered up things.
that's it. any other sort of weird stuff get's ignored. i.e. donkeys, crows, fog, beeped stuff. you may make a note in the groupcomments/groupstatus if you want. abusing filecomments for this is not wanted.