AniDB

Currently we have:

10 - Excellent
8 - Good
6 - Above average
5 - minimum requirements
3 - needs some improvement
1 - needs complete revision

"Meets minimum requirements" sounds like it`s matched a specific template.
I would request a rephrase for a few:

8 - Very good.
5 - Average (not bad, not good).
3 - Below average

And perhaps it`d be useful to add
- 7 (good)
- 4 (Needs some improvement)
to this list as well. I often feel like I don`t have enough options available to express my rating when a 6 sounds too low and an 8 too high.

Good stuff. Gets the squirrel stamp of approval, though I'd really just rather see the full scale available.

I agree with everything posted so far.

Why did you review this thread? I am just curious (sorry for bumping).

Some mods felt the ratings were useless and removed them, me and Gambit didn't agree but more disliked the ratings than liked them I guess.