Posted: Tue Jul 01, 2003 11:15 pm
I didn't say the reviews are pointless, just that they don't need a change IMHO. They already cover what we need from them, a point of view. ![Wink ;)](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
![Wink ;)](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
AniDB Archive Forum
https://forum.anidb.net/
:mymaster: ^^DonGato wrote:What you're talking is about censorship and I'm talking about democracy. Everyone should be left to review the way they like.
Perhaps there will be a few people who volunteer for this job, and then the community may vote whether these people will be handed that job, or rather not.zaufany wrote:Who will approve the reviews? There is a problem. If we choose everyone, to many reviews will be approved. We can choose few electors (ourselves), but it doesn’t sound democratic. We can say: “The forum community will decide.” This mean us too, but it sound very democratic.
yep..that has to be donezaufany wrote:I think we can now include the minimum length limit and deleting "Best anime ever all 10’s"
zaufany wrote:Who will approve the reviews? There is a problem. If we choose everyone, to many reviews will be approved. We can choose few electors (ourselves), but it doesn't sound democratic. We can say: “The forum community will decide.” This mean us too, but it sound very democratic.
you got it all wrong...there are no "moderators" likings..well there are but, the moderators wouldnt go deleting/not allowing something that totally differs from their opinion..the reviews that would be deleted/not allowed are only the "Best anime ever all 10’s" since they are completely useless..there is no informaion why this anime is best ever...DonGato wrote:I'm trying to save the review system... but the way you propose it's useless for me and I think lots of other people. I already know your 'moderators' likings.