AniDB

What rar wants is making the people feel discouraged about reporting their issues with votes about their reviews, as nobody will act for what you report in the forum most of the times. Anyway, reporting systems in places like this are prone to be abused. If you don't care about the extra work no pro...

To fahrenheit that is redoing the anime page, you might want to hide the temp vote if the date is before the current date. ;) That's because exp is lazy and didn't add something like that to the DB as I understand people might like to have their anticipation remembered by the DB but why all of us mu...

Binbou Shimai Monogatari: average slice-of-life story. Didn't like much the characters and the premise behind the 'plot', or maybe how it was executed. Bokura ga Ita : H&C rip-off? nani? It's a really good school love story. In the Kare Kano style but not that wicked. Recommended. Coyote Ragtime...

Juuni Kokuki, Hoshi no Koe, Rurouni Kenshin: Meiji Kenkaku Romantan - Tsuiokuhen... and a big list of others.

FMA is superv?
I thought it was good but nothing more than that...

Tithralad wrote:This is one of the best animes I ever watched!

How much anime you watched? Let's say 100 titles? 200? 400?
Or you have extremely bad luck picking your anime or you didn't watch too much...

If you don't like criticism, yes even that short one, you might better review in your own web site without any option for feedback.
I don't see people complaining about short comments in their 8/10 votes... that shows something. -_-;

Well, the main issue is that I thought of using it as something different than is now discussed. I thought about a personal comments on a series that might be or not shared with the people you share MyList with. I don't want a mini-review nor another group-comments like feature to have in the main p...

And a lot more, but maybe is better left without any continuation.

I do think that comments should be related to your MyList or MyVotes, not to the anime page and not shown to everyone. At least I don't want that. So: - Not even related/near reviews. - Not put in a main place. - Use the current permissions system. - Relate it to MyVotes or MyList (you can have anim...

No, no, no... not small sized reviews. Comments in my opinion is useful when you can have some information you might find interesting to remember and even share with some people (i.e. why you dropped it, why you gave it a good rating, that it can be recommended to people liking x style). Something l...

Since I can't imagine a person really has a reason for validly choosing a generic file and marking it as deleted, and yet still having the additional information. If a person chose a generic file, because they don't know which file they downloaded ... I don't see them picking "on dvd", et...

Well, the current review system has some limits (number of words to be written so you're able to submit it) and I don't think we should limit such comments. Currently I use the wishlist system to set comments on anime series I dropped.

Anime comments (private/shared with current mylist permissions) could be useful.