AniDB

I agree on this one too. I hate to go through all anime in the big list, just to see if there`s a review or not. I already replied with such a suggestion in another review-request thread here, but I guess it doesn`t mind replying here as well. 'Latest reviews' would fit nicely below the 'Latest file...

- If you leave the "minor changes"-box on, your edit will be directed to a [review] mod. The [review] mod then decides if you keep your previous rating or not. (In other words, the [review] mod decides if the users should be given the chance to change their opinion on the review due to th...

Well, we do have a rating system now, but that`s per review, not per reviewer. I believe it shouldn`t be much difficult to create your suggestion, and personally I`d like to see it as well.
So I`ll back you up

Since I didn't find a review worth deleting there 20 minutes later, I assume that you already deleted those nwa meant. For the sake of transparency, what were these reviews like? All 10/1 and "best/worst" ever? Too short? :? Mostly one- or twoliners, and half of them with all 10s. The rea...

My point is that I for example don't write reviews based on that guide..well, maybe only partly since I do talk about animation, sound and about the story separately but it is still different from the guide...so if you approve the reviews based on Gambit's guide(damn you review monopolizer :P ) the...

we only have 2 really active reviewers and these are Gambit and themug who have over 80 reviews..next one to come is aranaxon with 30+ reviews, but some of his reviews wouldnt fit into the character/word limit...the next should be me :D with 20 reviews..then petriw, requiem and some others..but mos...

Even though I think 100 words is a more appropriate way of setting a limit, I wouldn`t mind setting a 300 character min. limit instead. 100 characters are 2 lines, 300 characters would be 6 lines. If you`re able to write 6 lines about an anime, then you`re not a lame n00b who can`t write at all. 6 f...

phew! what shall I say? All of you have good points and valid concerns. It's not as if i could just say we do it this way or that way. I simply don't know myself how we should handle this. but i guess there are some basic things we all agree on: 1) there has to be some text on what is important whe...

Who will approve the reviews? There is a problem. If we choose everyone, to many reviews will be approved. We can choose few electors (ourselves), but it doesn’t sound democratic. We can say: “The forum community will decide.” This mean us too, but it sound very democr...

Lots of replies, so I`m gonna post here again. First of all, I don`t think an anime will be able to receive all 10s, if you consider it has to be perfect in 4 different categories, and you`ll have to think of it as something perfectly enjoying as well. Even the stuff I rated nearly perfect, I have t...

Another suggestion we came up with was: Review-moderator Someone who can 'approve' if a review is good enough or not, before publishing it. This will make sure that only decent to good reviews will be allowed. Bad idea if there aren`t any people who want to take up a job which involves that much inv...

What about the !stats command? It`s not too long, and it`s supposed to keep info about this kind of stuff anyway.

Same problem here ... everything disappears after using back(space). Using IE 5.0 or something ...

[10:36] <PetriW> Sheesh, what's up with voting 6x10... [10:36] <PetriW> http://anidb.ath.cx/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=animeatt&aid=26 [10:43] <PetriW> well, it might actually be worth all 10s ;) [10:44] <Gambit|wakingUp> How can that be? The series hasn`t even finished yet. [10:44] <PetriW> but ...

Currently MyList shows the general vote/review, but I think it would be nice to see your own vote/review beside it - or perhaps even replace the general vote. After all, why would you care about the general mark when you have it anyway? You want to see your own vote for that, to see if you liked it ...